We purchase them by the tens of hundreds and thousands many times with little thought but price. Are we missing something? Are there differences beyond the price point? What do you base your buying decisions on for such an important commodity in our industry? The following article poses the same questions to four of our leading rental shirt providers and gives you their thoughts as they sent them. I hope you can draw buying advice from this information. I hope we can make you think. After Six, Ascot LLC, Classix, and CSS Chaplin have contributed information and would love to do business with you.
Give us some background information about your company.
After Six: After Six Formalwear is a division of Sequa Corporation, a publicly-traded company that reported nearly $2 billion in sales at the end of fiscal 2005. At the end of third quarter 2006 corporate sales results were up 11% and operating profits up 9%. Sequa is headquartered in New York City and the After Six division is headquartered in Athens, Georgia. Shares of Sequa stock improved nearly 48% over the past 12 months from $86.25 to $128.19 a share as of February 15, 2007. Kathleen Peskens is president of the After Six division. The company produces tuxedos and accessories under the After Six, John Galante, and Seven Unlimited brands. They license the After Six name to the Barclay Formal Shoes division of Rocky Brands and to The Dessy Group which sells After Six bridesmaid dresses to over 1,200 bridal retailers in the U.S. After Six is the only men’s formalwear brand name in the bridal business.
Ascot LLC: Founded in 1997, Ascot LLC has grown to be the number one provider of “Better” formal shirts in the formalwear industry. In the spring of 1999, Ascot LLC introduced Luxe Microfiber as an alternative and future replacement to poly cotton rental shirts. Testing results have proven that Luxe Microfiber (exclusively distributed by Ascot LLC) is a far superior fabric to poly cotton. Over five hundred companies representing thousands of doors currently use our Luxe Microfiber rental shirts.
Classix: Classix was established in 1994. Over the last thirteen years it has become an important supplier of shirts to the formalwear industry.
CSS Chaplin: CSS was founded in 1986 by company president and owner Sam Kim. He began shipping his first shirts during prom season of 1987 from their original location in San Jose, CA.
Sales force?
After Six: We have four domestic representatives: Bobby Lucarelli-Western US & Canada, Tim Moore-Midwest, Ed Murphy-Southeast, Stu Feinberg-Northeast US and Eastern Canada, along with Pedro Bonilla in the Caribbean. We also have Leonard Bloom who sells retail products to large retail chains and handles our international accounts.
Ascot LLC: Ascot is partnered with FLOW Formal Alliance and shares the same salesmen. Richard Getty serves the NE and South. Ian Gibbs serves the Mid-Atlantic and Tom DeYoung travels the Midwest and West coast. Bob Milam, Vice President for Ascot, travels with the salesmen at different times but also extensively on his own promoting Ascot and its products.
Classix: In addition to marketing via the internet and postcards, we have 3 salespeople.
Chaplin: Canada, Roger March, 905-812-5500.
Eastern US including Texas, Jerry Mashman, 215-369-2875.
Western US, Ken Pendley, 303-549-2755.
What about manufacturing? Where? Do you use the same factory for other things? How much of your business is formalwear?
After Six: We prefer to keep our contractors confidential. However, we produce our tuxedos, pants, cummerbunds, vests and ties in Mexico and the Dominican Republic. Our shirts are produced in Korea. 95% of our business is formalwear with our newest market segment just revving up into “informalwear” for rental for destination and encore weddings along with informal events.
Ascot LLC: Most of our shirts are made in the Dominican Republic. We have also imported shirts from Italy and Korea. Recently, we launched a major new division of Hospitality and Career apparel, making Ascot one of the largest distributors of “Better” Formal and Career Apparel shirts in the United States.
Classix: 80% of our business is formalwear and 20% uniforms. We have been using the same factory in Korea for the last 13 years. This is the only way to keep consistent quality.
CSS Chaplin: Most of our shirts are made in China. Occasionally we may do some production in Korea on a quick turn around basis. The factory we use has production lines for many different types of products; however the main concentration is shirts. The overwhelming percentage of our business is in formalwear. But there are many uses for formalwear in the uniform market which makes up the balance of our business. We have many formalwear specialist and uniform stores that cater to schools, restaurants, hotels, etc.
Tell us about your facilities stateside?
After Six: We’re headquartered in Athens, Georgia. The facility encompasses 103,000 square feet of offices, customer service, product design, and warehouse space. We do little to no manufacturing in this facility today. Our tuxedos and pants come via truck from Mexico to Athens. The coats are individually seal-packed, bar-coded and hung in 18-wheelers while pants are boxed. Our accessory production is split between our Mexico and Dominican Republic facilities. No After Six products are manufactured outside of North America or the Caribbean other than our shirts which are manufactured in Korea. Of course, our licensee Barclay Formal Shoes, does manufacture in China.
Ascot LLC: We now operate out of two warehouse facilities located in Baltimore, MD.
Classix: Our facilities in Lancaster, CA, are a 20,000 sq ft state of the art building built for us in 2006.
CSS Chaplin: We operate our distribution center out of an 82,000 square foot building in Englewood, Co.
Stock on hand?
After Six: Unfortunately, as one of our major competitors all but abandoned the poly/cotton market, we have been overwhelmed by orders since the start of the year that we didn’t anticipate and are running very tight right now for the peak season. We have more shirts arriving, but they are being snatched up as quickly as they land in Athens.
Ascot LLC: We enter spring 2007 with the largest on-hand inventory ever in Ascot’s history.
Classix: We have over $1,500,000 inventory at all times about 214,000 pieces.
CSS Chaplin: It is generally felt by most of our customers that we carry the largest shirt inventory in the business.
How many shirt styles do you stock?
After Six: Essentially, we produce classic formal shirts in white only. ¼” pleats in wing and laydown-packaged or bulk, pintuck pleated wings for rental. ½” pleated French cuff, all cotton wing and laydown plus all of our rental shirts for retail, too.
Ascot LLC: Again, we are the largest provider of “Better” Formal shirts in the US. We carry an extensive number of styles. This would include shirts from our solid Luxe Collection, Luxe Micro Pleat Collection, Lyrics Stripe Collection, Shadow Stripe Collection, Lauren Ralph Lauren Retail Collection, and our new Hospitality and Career Apparel Collection.
Classix: 18 styles for men, 5 styles for women, and 10 styles for boys-- all in numerous colors.
CSS Chaplin: Approximately 50 different styles between strictly formal rental and retail shirts and those that serve both as formal and uniform shirts.
What is your number one rental shirt seller?
After Six: Today it is a balance of wing and laydown collar ¼” pleated poly/cotton blend shirt .
AscotLLC: Ascot LLC was the first company to introduce a non-pleated microfiber shirt to the formalwear industry. (shirt style “Bob laydown”) With over ten colors offered in this style, it has remained our top selling shirt for many years running.
Classix: MOO Wing collar ¼ “ pleat
CSS Chaplin: The "king of the hill" is still the white 1/4" pleat wing collar. But it has lost a good portion of its market share to pleated down collars and microfibers.
Aside from rental shirts what is something you sell we may not be aware of?
After Six: Our business-to-business website is open 24/7/365. Many customers don’t realize they can access our inventories, place orders, track a shipment, and order marketing materials whenever they want at www.aftersix.com. Our customers that use it love it. When our customer service team leaves at 5pm EST, and your store is still open, you can still place an order online for whatever you need and it’s shipped the next day! Best of all, it emails you an order confirmation!
Ascot LLC: Our Lauren Ralph Lauren retail collection. We hold the exclusive rights to this label for formal shirts. Multiple styles in 100% cotton are in stock and immediately available.
Classix: Jewelry cufflinks, bow ties and cummerbunds.
CSS Chaplin: We have carried a full line of polyester coats, pants, skirts, and vests for the hospitality industry for many years. Most recently though we have expanded into 100% wool rental coats, 100% wool rental pants, super 100's rental pants, super 100's retail tuxedos, and a line of polysatin full back rental vests.
Why should we buy your basic white wing shirt?
After Six: The After Six brand name is the most recognized name in formalwear, which is very important if you’re selling packaged rental shirts. Our quality is very consistent and our size range covers everybody. Customers love our bulk prices.
Ascot LLC: Ascot’s new 1’4” pleat in Luxe Microfiber never shrinks, fades, and is even easier to maintain than basic poly cotton rental shirts.
Classix: We have the best and consistent quality. We have all the sizes XS to 6XL in stock all the time. We have sleeve lengths to 41” and we ship the same day you order.
CSS Chaplin: Because it’s the best shirt for the money out there and it is backed up by superior inventory levels and commitment to quality by all at CSS.
How does the white wing shirt you sell today compare with the one you sold 5 years ago?
After Six: We’ve added the comfort collar. We also make our shirt bodies and pleats longer than most. This eliminates having to buy tall man shirts. Our shirt sizes are available to an 8XL-40. We offer men’s shirts starting with an XS-30/31 to 36/37 instead of starting at S-30/31.
Ascot LLC: Poly cotton five years ago versus Luxe Microfiber today - A one round knockout in favor of Luxe Microfiber!
Classix: It’s exactly the same. We have only improved the fabric and the sewing.
CSS Chaplin: All of our rental shirts come with our EZ fit collar. Additionally, we now make our shirts with what we believe to be the longest body and bib length in the industry.
What does the future hold for this same shirt?
After Six: Classic elegance. Cost-effective. Great Value for the Price. If you’re asking if wing collars are the future, that means are you asking if bow ties will come back? We’ve seen Hollywood wearing bow ties again, but not necessarily with wing collars.
Ascot LLC: “The future rental shirt for the formalwear industry is microfiber.” Saul Offit stated in 1999 after returning from a fabric show in Italy where he found Luxe Microfiber. When an operator can have a shirt product that will out last and out perform the status quo of poly cotton and also make more money for their company, why anything else? Fact: hundreds of companies, representing over one thousand doors, have GROWN their bottom line by up-charging for fashion and basic Luxe Microfiber shirts.
Classix: It is the only definitive tux shirt. At present we have 10,417 pieces in stock.
CSS Chaplin: We believe it will remain the most widely used shirt for some time to come in both the formalwear and uniform markets.
What about microfiber? As a manufacturer, what place do you feel this has in the rental world?
After Six: We have chosen to not enter that arena at this time. There are other sources for these and for us to enter this arena today would just mean us having to commodity price to capture sales which doesn’t make sense.
Ascot LLC: Luxe Microfiber is the number 1 rental fabric for the rental industry.
Classix: Microfiber will be 20 to 25% of the market but not more than that.
CSS Chaplin: Between pleatless wing and down collar and 1/4" pleat wing and down we carry 14 different microfibers. They have captured an increasingly larger share of our overall production, and it appears that they will continue to do so.
What does the future hold for microfiber versus poly cotton rental shirts?
After Six: As far as we are concerned, formalwear is pleated, period. The more the industry moves to non-pleated shirts, the less consumers see a need for true formal shirts. We know there is a pleated microfiber, which is on the right path. For the rental business, maybe microfiber is the easy way to go for some, but it certainly hasn’t been a hot item on the menswear scene.
Ascot LLC: Why anything poly cotton! We believe that the entire industry should be placing their new orders and fill-ins with Luxe Microfiber from Ascot. Why? We now know that our microfiber will out perform and outlast standard poly cotton by more than a two to one ratio. Luxe Microfiber never shrinks, fades, and is easier to clean and press than poly cotton. You not only make more money when renting our shirts, but also save money in the backroom.
Classix: As stated above it will be 20-25% of the market.
CSS Chaplin: Microfiber has become a very important part of most retailers’ rental lines, but the poly cottons are still at the top of usage.
What mistakes do you see retailers making in rental shirt purchases?
After Six: Like our competitors, we’d like to own everyone’s shirt business. For us to sit here and tell retailers how to run their businesses and how to buy products doesn’t make sense. If you can find a better price-value shirt than ours, buy it. If not, buy ours!
Classix: They buy 1 and 2 pieces at a time and pay UPS and Fed Ex a lot of money in shipping. They should order a minimum of 6 per order and the most economical shipping.
CSS Chaplin: Each year it seems that the most commonly used sizes move around, i.e. M5's one year and XL5's the next. It is very difficult for the specialist to plan season orders without tracking the previous season’s usages by size.
Even or odd sleeves--which way should we go?
After Six: We make ours odd sleeve, so we’ll go with odd. We produce odds up through 39 but also offer a 40 sleeve in select sizes. We have customers that use both odd and even sleeves and others that refuse to mix them.
Classix: All of our shirts are odd sleeves. We made a decision to go with odd sleeves. To add even we need two sets of inventory.
CSS Chaplin: We currently make both the even and odd scales in several of our basic rental shirts. We believe that the odd scale covers a broader range of sizes that the even.
Is the comfort collar feature a selling point for you?
After Six:It’s a benefit expected of every manufacturer. Not everyone likes it but it does reduce exchanges at the store and at the wholesaler level. We were one of the last to move to it and most of our customers have appreciated the move. If a large man likes his collar to fit snug, any comfort collar can gap open a bit, but those customers’ issues are minimal. We like to believe our comfort collar is the best made.
Ascot LLC: Every rental shirt produced by Ascot has the Comfort Collar feature.
Classix: Yes, sometimes.
CSS Chaplin: We first introduced our EZ fit collar in 1994 and it immediately became a large selling point for us.
What life expectancy do you as a manufacturer see your standard rental white wing having?
After Six: Depending on your process and chemicals 30-45 turns.
Ascot LLC: Remember, test results show that Luxe Microfiber will last longer than poly cotton by more than a two to one ratio.
Classix: 30-40 washing cycles
CSS Chaplin: With normal wear, proper care and laundering procedures a shirt should get 35 to 45 turns.
Any last thoughts on why we should use your company’s shirts?
After Six: Simply stated, we want your basic shirt business, but only if we can do it profitably for both of us.
Ascot LLC: Ascot LLC offers multiple new “Avenues to Revenue” with Luxe Microfiber rental shirts. Change is Inevitable…Growth is Optional. If you rent Luxe Microfiber, your ROI will be much higher (front room to back room) than if you only offer poly cotton.
Classix: We have the best shirts and the best service in the industry. We have all shirts in stock all the time. We ship the same day you order.
CSS Chaplin: See all of the above!
Contact information by region if necessary
After Six www.aftersix.com
West Bobby Lucarelli blafter6@charter.net
Midwest Tim Moore aftersix@sbcglobal.net
Southeast Ed Murphy edmurphy@cctsi.net
Northeast Stu Feinberg stuartifeinberg@aol.com
International Leonard Bloom tux2222@yahoo.com
_______________________________________________________________________
Ascot LLC Bob Milam
Vice President, Ascot LLC
888-574-7577
_______________________________________________________________________
Classix Vahe Khachooni
Vice President
42450 12th street West
Lancaster, CA 93534
800-934-3290
________________________________________________________________________
CSS Chaplin
Canada Roger March 905-812-5500.
Eastern US including Texas Jerry Mashman 215-369-2875.
Western US Ken Pendley 303-549-2755.
________________________________________________________________________
Any questions or input on Rental shirts please send to rebeccamc522@aol.com